B&W / Color, 1969, 85 mins. 7 secs.
Directed by Robert Downey
Starring Arnold Johnson, Laura Greene, Allen Garfield, Buddy Butler, Antonio Fargas
Vinegar Syndrome (Blu-ray & DVD) (US R0 HD/NTSC), Criterion, Rhino, Home Vision (DVD) (US R1 NTSC)
When the head of a Madison Avenue ad firm dies, the board members -- each thinking he's the only one who would cast a dissenting vote -- unwittingly elect their sole black member, Putney Swope (Johnson, voiced hilariously by Downey himself), as their new leader. He proceeds to fire almost everyone and starts off with the best intentions, renaming the firm Truth and Soul Inc. and refusing any clients tied to cigarettes or the war. However, the nature of the marketplace proves more complicated than he could have imagined, and it becomes harder to keep body and soul together.
The Vinegar Syndrome edition easily marks the most elaborate presentation of the film to date, complete with a shockingly excellent transfer from a new 4K restoration created by the Academy Film Archive and the George Lucas Family Film Foundation. The aspect ratio of this film has been a somewhat tricky issue over the years; it was shot 1.33:1 and more or less left safe for masking up to 1.85:1 in theaters, though the main titles have always been 1.33:1 on every version on home video regardless of any other variations. The Vinegar Syndrome transfer opens the film up completely to 1.33:1 throughout, which seems like the wisest choice given the tightness of the compositions. The English DTS-HD MA 1.0 mono track is also pristine (considering the ridiculous nature of the original sound mix), and optional English SDH subtitles are provided.
The prior Downey track is ported over here, though new viewers would be better off starting with a new, second audio commentary by Sergio Mims, who previously did honors on Penitentiary and Sweet Sweetback's Baadassssss Song. He really knows his stuff and lays out plenty of context for this film as part of an ongoing run of satires on the world of advertising, the future Hollywood contributions of some participants, the impact of Broadway and other stage productions of the era (including the casting of Fargas), the nature of American politics at the time, the issues inherent in trying to please everyone in black cinema, and ties to films all the way up to Boogie Nights. You also get video interviews with Downey from the 2001 Rhino disc (16m8s) and 2008 (11m32s) about how his background at a film house led to this film and his own views on filmmaking at the time, as well as the loose and free nature of productions at the time. He's also present for a very lo-fi 2005 Q&A at the 2005 Philadelphia Film Festival (25m13s), which covers much of the same territory but with far queasier camerawork. Also included is an audio interview with cinematographer Gerald Cotts (19m41s) conducted by Brad Henderson, chatting about the process of mounting Downey's first "normal" movie, the perceived danger of the subject matter, cinematic visual influences (or lack thereof), and more. The very basic theatrical trailer is also included along with a gallery (6m) of promotional material and press coverage.